A victory for common sense

I’m Peter Webster, chief executive of Corps Security, and this is where I examine the issues affecting the security industry. My thoughts and opinions are intended to generate debate and whether you agree or disagree with them, you’re welcome to post your comments below.


Following a tumultuous few months, the question about whether Scotland should become an independent country has been answered and I’m delighted that common sense has prevailed. The arguments made from either side were generally thought provoking, engaging and divisive, usually in equal measure, but ultimately the view that Scotland is stronger, safer and more secure as part of the UK has been recognised by the country’s electorate.

I applaud this rational and pragmatic decision, and hope that now the issue has been ‘put to bed’, we can move forward as a truly united nation.

I addressed many of my concerns about what independence would have meant for Scotland in a previous blog and since writing it the Yes Scotland campaign did little to allay my fears, with an argument that appeared to be based more on emotion than hard headed economics. In fact, on a number of key issues it consistently failed to offer any real answers or alternatives to the status quo.

Obviously, questions still remain, particularly with regard to the promises made about further devolved powers. Details about exactly what these will be was the subject of much speculation on the run up to the vote but it was stated that that the final say on funding for the NHS will be a matter for the Scottish government because of the continuation of the Barnett allocation for resources, and the powers of the Scottish parliament to raise revenues. This has, in turn, created its own controversy, particularly with regard to the impact it will have on England.

When Standard Life confirmed that it would move its operations south if the yes vote won, the economic risks suddenly became very real and as a company with significant business interests and operations north or the border, we shared this concern.

This concern grew on the eve of the vote, when a poll suggested that the gap between the yes and no camps was just two percentage points. Fortunately, the nature of how we operate in Scotland will not change and the long-term future for our extensive manned guarding operations in Glasgow, Edinburgh and Aberdeen, our support centre, and the Corps Monitoring Centre (CMC) has been assured.

I’ve been dismayed by the implication that those who voted no are somehow less patriotic that those who voted the opposite way. I think both parties were equally committed to maintaining Scottish identity, culture and values and I hope that this some of the negative rhetoric within families, communities and businesses can be eradicated, and that the Scottish nation comes together as a valued member of the UK.

It has been a truly historic occasion and it is great to see democracy in action in this way. However, as I finish this blog I can only feel an enormous sense of relief about what has transpired.

Follow Peter on Twitter
Connect with Peter on LinkedIn 

One thought on “A victory for common sense

  1. An excellent piece Peter, I particularly like and agree with, your comments about the unquestionable loyalty of both yes and no voters.

    For reasons which extend beyond pure economics, I’m truly delighted that Scotland remains part of the Union – as an English man who spends a lot of my spare time in the Commonwealth War Graves of Northern Europe, I appreciate just how closely our countries are bound by a shared sense of common decency and the determination to do the right things, in the right way and for the right reasons. I for one am extremely proud to have Scotland as a neighbour and whilst I appreciate fully the desire held by the yes voters for a formalised independence, I am absolutely delighted that common sense has prevailed!

    An excellent results and an excellent blog!

    Gary Broad

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s